CLIでは取得できても, SNMPでは取得できないMACアドレス.

  • MIB ".1.3.6.1.2.1.17.4.3.1.1" をnet-snmpのsnmpwalkで取得すると右辺にスイッチが学習したMACアドレスを取得することができるが, スイッチが学習したアドレスの中には取得できないものがある.
  • MACアドレスが全て"20"から"7e"までの間にある場合には, このアドレスはログインしてshow mac address-tableで表示させることはできても, "snmpwalk -c コミュニティ名 -v 1 スイッチ名 .1.3.6.1.2.1.17.4.3.1.1"では取得できない.
    • 最上位は1ビット広がって,"19"から"7f"の範囲になる.
  • 例:"arping -0 -s 20:20:20:20:20:20 -p 適当なIPアドレス" としてソースMACアドレスを20:20:20:20:20:20にしたパケットを発信してみると, Ciscoスイッチはこのアドレスを学習していてもsnmpwalkには存在していない.
  • 例:"arping -0 -s 20:20:20:20:7f:20 -p 適当なIPアドレス" としてソースMACアドレスを20:20:20:20:7f:20にしたパケットを発信してみると, snmpwalkにも"Hex-STRING: 20 20 20 20 7F 20"という応答がある.
  • net-snmpのバージョンにはよらない.
  • IOSのバージョンにはよらない. さらに古いCatOSの一部でも同じ結果. かなり以前からこういう仕様になっているらしい?
  • 該当する可能性があるハードウエアメーカー. Apple,Sonyの他,Ciscoも入っている.
    • 各メーカーとも下三桁の((6*16-1)/256)^3=5.1%に該当の可能性がある.
20:41:5A	Smarteh_d_o_o
20:44:3A	Schneider_Electric_Asia_Pacific
20:4E:6B	Axxana_israel_ltd
20:54:76	Sony_Mobile_Communications_AB
20:5B:2A	PRIVATE
20:5B:5E	Shenzhen_Wonhe_Technology_Co_Lt
20:64:32	SAMSUNG_ELECTRO_MECHANICS_CO_LT
24:37:4C	Cisco_SPVTG
24:3C:20	Dynamode_Group
24:49:7B	Innovative_Converged_Devices_In
24:69:4A	Jasmine_Systems_Inc
24:76:7D	Cisco_SPVTG
28:37:37	Apple_Inc
28:41:21	OptiSense_Network_LLC
28:48:46	GridCentric_Inc
28:4C:53	Intune_Networks
28:51:32	Shenzhen_Prayfly_Technology_Co_
28:60:46	Lantech_Communications_Global_I
2C:21:72	Juniper_Networks
2C:2D:48	bct_electronic_GesmbH
2C:30:68	Pantech_Co_Ltd
2C:34:27	ERCO_amp_GENER
2C:3A:28	Fagor_Electr_nica
2C:3F:38	Cisco_Systems
2C:3F:3E	Alge_Timing_GmbH
2C:41:38	Hewlett_Packard_Company
2C:54:2D	Cisco_Systems
2C:62:5A	Finest_Security_Systems_Co_Ltd
30:38:55	Nokia_Corporation
30:39:26	Sony_Ericsson_Mobile_Communicat
30:39:55	Shenzhen_Jinhengjia_Electronic_
30:41:74	ALTEC_LANSING_LLC
30:49:3B	Nanjing_Z_Com_Wireless_Co_Ltd
30:4C:7E	Panasonic_Electric_Works_Automa
30:52:5A	NST_Co_LTD
30:5D:38	Beissbarth
30:69:4B	RIM
30:6E:5C	Validus_Technologies
30:7C:30	RIM
34:25:5D	Shenzhen_Loadcom_Technology_Co_
34:2F:6E	Anywire_corporation
34:4B:3D	Fiberhome_Telecommunication_Tec
34:4B:50	ZTE_Corporation
34:4F:69	EKINOPS_SAS
34:68:4A	Teraworks_Co_Ltd
34:78:77	O_NET_Communications_Shenzhen_L
34:7E:39	Nokia_Danmark_A_S
38:60:77	PEGATRON_CORPORATION
38:6E:21	Wasion_Group_Ltd
3C:27:63	SLE_quality_engineering_GmbH_am
3C:2F:3A	SFORZATO_Corp
3C:36:3D	Nokia_Corporation
3C:3A:73	Avaya_Inc
3C:4C:69	Infinity_System_S_L
3C:4E:47	Etronic_A_S
3C:5A:37	Samsung_Electronics
3C:62:78	SHENZHEN_JETNET_TECHNOLOGY_CO_L
3C:67:2C	Sciovid_Inc
3C:6A:7D	Niigata_Power_Systems_Co_Ltd
3C:6F:45	Fiberpro_Inc
3C:70:59	MakerBot_Industries
3C:74:37	RIM
3C:75:4A	Motorola_Mobility_Inc
40:33:6C	Godrej_Boyce_Mfg_co_ltd
40:40:22	ZIV
40:40:6B	Icomera
40:55:39	Cisco_Systems
40:60:5A	Hawkeye_Tech_Co_Ltd
40:66:7A	mediola_connected_living_AG
40:70:4A	Power_Idea_Technology_Limited
40:70:74	Life_Technology_China_Co_Ltd
44:2A:60	Apple_Inc
44:32:2A	Avaya_Inc
44:37:6F	Young_Electric_Sign_Co
44:38:39	Cumulus_Networks_inc
44:3D:21	Nuvolt
44:4F:5E	Pan_Studios_Co_Ltd
44:58:29	Cisco_SPVTG
44:5F:7A	Shihlin_Electric_Engineering_Co
44:61:32	ecobee_inc
44:6C:24	Reallin_Electronic_Co_Ltd
44:6D:57	Liteon_Technology_Corporation
48:28:2F	ZTE_Corporation
48:34:3D	IEP_GmbH
48:5B:39	ASUSTek_COMPUTER_INC
48:5D:60	Azurewave_Technologies_Inc
4C:32:2D	TELEDATA_NETWORKS
4C:3B:74	VOGTEC_H_K_Co_Ltd
4C:4B:68	Mobile_Device_Inc
4C:54:27	Linepro_Sp_z_o_o
4C:73:67	Genius_Bytes_Software_Solutions
4C:77:4F	Embedded_Wireless_Labs
50:22:67	PixeLINK
50:25:2B	Nethra_Imaging_Incorporated
50:2A:7E	Smart_electronic_GmbH
50:39:55	Cisco_SPVTG
50:3F:56	Syncmold_Enterprise_Corp
50:46:5D	ASUSTek_COMPUTER_INC
50:4A:5E	Masimo_Corporation
50:56:63	Texas_Instruments
50:60:28	Xirrus_Inc
50:64:41	Greenlee
50:72:4D	BEG_Brueck_Electronic_GmbH
50:79:5B	Interexport_Telecomunicaciones_
50:7E:5D	Arcadyan_Technology_Corporation
54:31:31	Raster_Vision_Ltd
54:39:68	Edgewater_Networks_Inc
54:42:49	Sony_Corporation
54:46:6B	Shenzhen_CZTIC_Electronic_Techn
58:2F:42	Universal_Electric_Corporation
58:34:3B	Glovast_Technology_Ltd
58:50:76	Linear_Equipamentos_Eletronicos
58:69:6C	Fujian_Ruijie_Networks_co_ltd
58:75:21	CJSC_RTSoft
58:76:75	Beijing_ECHO_Technologies_Co_Lt
5C:24:79	Baltech_AG
5C:35:3B	Compal_Broadband_Networks_Inc
5C:40:58	Jefferson_Audio_Video_Systems_I
5C:4A:26	Enguity_Technology_Corp
5C:51:4F	Intel_Corporate
5C:59:48	Apple_Inc
5C:6A:7D	KENTKART_EGE_ELEKTRONIK_SAN_VE_
5C:6B:32	Texas_Instruments
5C:6D:20	Hon_Hai_Precision_Ind_Co_Ltd
5C:6F:4F	S_A_SISTEL
5C:77:57	Haivision_Network_Video
60:2A:54	CardioTek_B_V
60:33:4B	Apple_Inc
60:35:53	Buwon_Technology
60:45:5E	Liptel_s_r_o
60:54:64	Eyedro_Green_Solutions_Inc
60:67:20	Intel_Corporate
60:6C:66	Intel_Corporate
60:73:5C	Cisco
64:27:37	Hon_Hai_Precision_Ind_Co_Ltd
64:31:50	Hewlett_Packard_Company
64:31:7E	Dexin_Corporation
64:43:46	GuangDong_Quick_Network_Compute
64:4D:70	dSPACE_GmbH
64:4F:74	LENUS_Co_Ltd
64:51:7E	LONG_BEN_DONGGUAN_ELECTRONIC_TE
64:54:22	Equinox_Payments
64:55:63	Intelight_Inc
64:6E:6C	Radio_Datacom_LLC
64:76:57	Innovative_Security_Designs
64:7C:34	Ubee_Interactive_Corp
68:23:4B	Nihon_Dengyo_Kousaku
68:43:52	Bhuu_Limited
68:5B:36	POWERTECH_INDUSTRIAL_CO_LTD
68:5D:43	Intel_Corporate
68:5E:6B	PowerRay_Co_Ltd
68:63:59	Advanced_Digital_Broadcast_SA
68:6E:23	Wi3_Inc
68:72:51	Ubiquiti_Networks
68:78:4C	Nortel_Networks
68:79:24	ELS_GmbH_Co_KG
6C:20:56	Cisco
6C:2E:33	Accelink_Technologies_Co_Ltd
6C:3E:6D	Apple_Inc
6C:50:4D	Cisco_Systems
6C:5D:63	ShenZhen_Rapoo_Technology_Co_Lt
6C:5E:7A	Ubiquitous_Internet_Telecom_Co_
6C:62:6D	Micro_Star_INT_L_CO_LTD
6C:70:39	Novar_GmbH
70:25:26	Alcatel_Lucent
70:2F:4B	PolyVision_Inc
70:3C:39	SEAWING_Kft
70:46:42	CHYNG_HONG_ELECTRONIC_CO_LTD
70:70:4C	Purple_Communications_Inc
70:72:3C	Huawei_Technologies_Co_Ltd
70:7E:43	Motorola_Mobility_Inc
74:27:3C	ChangYang_Technology_Nanjing_Co
74:2F:68	Azurewave_Technologies_Inc
74:31:70	Arcadyan_Technology_Corporation
74:32:56	NT_ware_Systemprg_GmbH
74:4D:79	Arrive_Systems_Inc
74:53:27	COMMSEN_CO_LIMITED
74:7B:7A	ETH_Inc
74:7E:2D	Beijing_Thomson_CITIC_Digital_T
78:22:3D	Affirmed_Networks
78:25:44	Omnima_Limited
78:44:76	Zioncom_technology_co_ltd
78:52:62	Shenzhen_Hojy_Software_Co_Ltd
78:59:3E	RAFI_GmbH_Co_KG
78:5C:72	Hioso_Technology_Co_Ltd
78:61:7C	MITSUMI_ELECTRIC_CO_LTD
7C:20:64	Alcatel_Lucent_IPD
7C:33:6E	MEG_Electronics_Inc
7C:38:6C	Real_Time_Logic
7C:39:20	SSOMA_SECURITY
7C:4B:78	Red_Sun_Synthesis_Pte_Ltd
7C:4C:58	Scale_Computing_Inc
7C:6B:33	Tenyu_Tech_Co_Ltd
7C:6B:52	Tigaro_Wireless
7C:6C:39	PIXSYS_SRL
7C:6D:62	Apple_Inc
7C:76:73	ENMAS_GmbH
7C:7D:41	Jinmuyu_Electronics_Co_Ltd